A St. Louis, the Rittenbergs, got a surprise when they got home and open the box that was supposed to have contained a brand new Sony Camcorder that they had purchased at a Best Buy store for $1600. They opened the box and found a bottle of pasta sauce inside rather than the camcorder.

When the couple contacted the store regarding their find, store officials told them that the box was sealed so the switch couldn’t have happened in their store, and that it must have happened at the Sony warehouse. Best Buy officials haven’t made a decision yet on how to handle the dispute. The Rittenbergs say that they are not thieves and that they filed a police report upon making their saucy discovery.